
Payal
I shut the door behind bhai, and I moved back and sat down on the bed.
I couldn’t stand it, the way he spoke to me, the way he looked at me. He acted like he cared about me, but if he cared for me, he couldn’t have let my sister leave. He wouldn’t have let Khushi go. Or even if she had still managed to go, he would have found her by now. He wouldn’t have married someone else, no matter what the circumstances had been.
Going over to my dresser, I pulled out my little box and opened it. Inside were envelopes containing all the letters that Khushi had sent me over the years. She didn’t write often, tops of maybe 3 times a year. But there was never a return address so I could never write back to her.
I pulled out a letter at random and found that it was the first ever one she wrote to me after leaving. Taking it out of its envelope, I sat down with it.
“Dear Jiji,
I hope my letter finds you in good health. I am doing well, I was unwell for a while, but I am well now. I know that you are probably really angry at me for leaving and not telling you, but I couldn’t do anything. Even the night before I left, I didn’t know that that would be the last night I would spend at the Raizada house with my husband. I didn’t plan to leave… It’s just something I had to do. I’m sure by now you are aware what happened. But I am writing to you to explain what I was thinking when I left. What caused me to decide to leave.
Initially, even after Nimisha returned, I didn’t plan on leaving. I was ready to stay with Arnav, to support him through her pregnancy. I knew he loved me, and no matter what happened, he would always care for me. But then I thought about it and realised that if I stayed, his priorities would always be with me. And as much as I wanted that, I realised that that wasn’t fair or right. He may not love Nimisha any more, but he did at one point, and she’s carrying the evidence of his love. He may not love her any more, but that baby is still his. The baby deserves his love and if I’m there, he’ll never be able to accept the baby.
I hope you can understand why I did what I did. I hope that you support my decision and that you forgive me for leaving without telling you. Maybe one day I will return, or maybe I’ll just come to see you, but right now, I think it would be best if I just stayed away.
Take care of yourself Jiji, and if he needs comfort, please be there for him. Reassure him that I love him more than I love my own life, and it’s because I love him that I have had to leave. Tell him that no matter how far I am from him, I will never forget about him, that I will never stop loving him. But sometimes, even those who truly love each other cannot be together. And that is us.
I will write again soon, I promise.
I love you always Jiji and you will always be in my thoughts and prayers.
Khushi.
PS: I know I haven’t given a return address, but it’s because I don’t want anyone to know where I am. If anyone knows, Arnav will come looking for me, and he can’t find me. For the sake of the baby, he can’t find me.”
Tears streamed down my face. I remember receiving this letter for the first time, I remember the initial shock. I was still so angry at her, I couldn’t understand why she wouldn’t give me her address or her number. I’m still angry with her.
I put the letter back and pull out a different one. I opened it up and realised that it was the one I received a few months after my wedding.
“To my dearest Jiji,
I hope you are doing very, very well!
I am doing fine. I’ve been working (what’s new, all I seem to do is work) and that’s about all I have been doing. It’s been a few years, but I feel like I’m really settling into my new life now. I’m hoping that’s the case for Arnav as well. Although, I feel like maybe he would’ve settled a long time ago.
I don’t really have much to say in this letter, I just wanted to check in on you so that you know I am well and that I’m happy.
I will write again,
Love you,
Your Khushi.”
This had been such a short letter, but it meant so much. If there had been a return address, the response to this letter would have been a very long one. I would’ve told her about my marriage.
When me and Akash got married, it was hard. I feel like I didn’t enjoy my wedding and the build up to my wedding the way I should’ve done. My sister should have been by my side, the way I had been for her at her wedding. But she wasn’t here and I was alone.
Even after getting married I struggled. Me and Akash didn’t consummate our marriage for over a week after we got married. I don’t know why, I couldn’t do it. My sister should’ve been here. She should’ve been in this very house. She should have been in the bedroom beside mine, but she wasn’t.
Wiping my tears away, I pulled out another envelope and took out the letter. This was the second letter she ever wrote to me, and only came a few weeks after the first.
“Dear Jiji,
I hope you are well. I am relatively well considering the circumstances.
I read in the newspaper the other day that Arnav and Nimisha had got married. I must admit, it did come as a shock to me. I had imagined them raising their child together, but it never occurred to me that they would marry. Maybe that was me being naive. Perhaps I should’ve realised that this would happen. But regardless, I was shocked when I read the news and I must admit, it did upset me a bit. I wanted him to move on and be happy with his baby… I just didn’t think I’d be replaced so soon. But I am glad he is happy. He deserves to be happy.
I guess there really is no space in his life for me any more, I guess I won’t be coming back into his life.
I really miss you Jiji. Maybe soon we can meet up one day? I don’t know.
Take care of yourself Jiji and take care of Amma and babuji and buaji. Tell them all that I love them and I miss them all so very much.
Tell Arnav… No don’t tell him anything.
I will write again soon Jiji, take care of yourself, I love you.
Love,
Khushi.”
She thought Arnav bhai got married out of choice. She thought he moved on and was ready to start afresh. He wasn’t. He didn’t want to get married, Di and Nani made him in order to save Nimisha and the Raizada family name. They didn’t want the Raizada heir to be born to an unwed mother. The wedding had been a small affair. Family only. Even me, Amma, babuji and buaji hadn’t been invited. But I guess it made sense. It would have been weird for us to see him get married to someone else.
I remember Arnav bhai coming to see me after the wedding, he had actually cried. He asked for my forgiveness, reassured me that he loved Khushi and only Khushi. That he would remain loyal to her for as long as he lived. As far as what I know, he stuck to this promise, he did remain loyal to Khushi. As much as I didn’t like Nimi, we did talk and I knew from her that to this day, she and bhai have not shared any kind of relationship and that their marriage still hasn’t been consummated.
That day he had cried some more, saying he didn’t want any of this, he just wanted Khushi back. He begged me to tell him if I knew where she was, if I had heard from her. I told him the truth, that I didn’t know where she was and I told him about the letter. He asked if he could read it and I took it out and gave it to him.
I’d watched as he sat and cried as he read her words. It felt so weird, seeing him cry like that. I was so angry at Khushi in that moment. She shouldn’t be making him cry like that.
She should be here, happy, by his side. But she wasn’t.
I kept going through the letters, reading them all one after another. All her letters came to our house and Amma would tell me to go and collect it.
Finally finding the last letter, I started reading it again.
“Jiji! How are you? I hope you are doing very very very well! I am well, I have been busy with life, but not a moment has passed when I haven’t thought about all of you guys.
I was in bed the other night and I thought about something. I have been gone for almost 6 years! I didn’t even realise so much time had passed! It also hit me that you have probably got married! And you may even have your own Aloo Kumar or Puri Kumari! I don’t know why I hadn’t thought of this before!
Well if you are married and if you do have a child, please say hi to jijaji for me and give a BIG kiss to my sweet niece or nephew. Tell them that even though they don’t know me, I love them.
Jiji, I miss you all the time. You are probably the person I miss the most. I wish I could come to see you, but I fear that if I come, I won’t be able to leave again.
How are Amma, babuji and buaji? Please tell them that I am always thinking about them and that I love them more than anything.
I love you all so so much,
Khushi.”
In this letter she had mentioned children and I wanted to tell her about Akshay. She didn’t know, didn’t have a clue that he existed and that hurt. She should know! She should have been here to spoil her nephew. But she wasn’t.
In Khushi’s letters she asked about Arnav bhai less and less, and it made me think, had she moved on with life? Six years is a long time, and a lot has changed, had she met someone else and started a new life? Or had she just come to terms with the fact that he had a new life and she was no longer a part of it?
I remember her telling me years ago that she had a job and it made me wonder if she was still working. I wondered what she was like, was she still the same old Khushi or had she changed?
Over the years, I’d searched her up on Facebook, I’d googled her, even called up random businesses asking if she worked for them, but there was no trace. Khushi had vanished. If it weren’t for these letters, one would think she fell off the face of the earth. Bhai knew people everywhere, and had people from all over find out if they could find her, but no one came up with any results. He had travelled from city to city, looking for her, but he couldn’t find her. She was missing.
When we were kids and when we played hide and seek, I would always win. I’d always find Khushi. Sometimes it took me all of 5 minutes, other times slightly longer. But I always found her, no matter where she was hiding. Why was I struggling now? Why hadn’t I been able to find her yet?
Wiping my tears away, I put all the letters back and closed the box. Maybe that’s what I needed to do. Put all my memories and emotions related to Khushi into a box and put them away. Maybe it was time to finally let get and move on with life…
Maybe.


